• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Lucy's New York Style Pizza

At Lucy's New York Style Pizza, we embrace the authentic flavors and traditions of New York, right in the heart of Orem, UT. Our journey began with a simple passion for crafting delicious, hand-tossed pizzas using fresh, high-quality ingredients. From our renowned Buffalo Pizza to the innovative Pickle Pizza, each creation reflects our commitment to flavor and creativity. Locals celebrate us as the go-to spot for genuine New York-style pizza, often choosing Lucy's for their family gatherings and special occasions. With a cozy atmosphere and dedicated service, we invite you to experience why pizza lovers keep coming back to Lucy's for their slice of happiness.

Lucy's New York Style Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Dallin Knudson
Dallin Knudson

Just got myself a beautiful pizza stone and Lucy’s pizza was kind enough to sell me they’re amazing pizza dough and it was spectacular! Thank you so much for making my family weekend with your amazing pizza! If you have not been to Lucy‘s yet, you truly don’t love pizza at all

Tori Bright
Tori Bright

This is the best pizza in Utah, as far as I’m concerned. My husband’s side of the family are a bunch of New Yorkers and eating pizza with them has made me a New York-style pizza snob. Many places claim to have it, but Lucy’s actually does! When we celebrated my husband’s grandma, a “New York girl,” the New Yorkers in the family chose Lucy’s to be part of her celebration of life party to pay homage to her upbringing. That party was the beginning of my Lucy’s pizza love affair. For good New York-style pizza make sure to try this out! The decorations are nice and create a comfortable dining environment.

Natalie
Natalie

This pizza was delicious! Thin crust that was tasty and excellent sauce. They offer a lunch special, however ; we ordered a whole pie for leftovers. Our server suggested we try the Firesticks, those are awesome if you like a little spice in your life! They also had really good Ranch for a dipping sauce. Our server was great, the pizza was wood fired and excellent. I suggest you check it out for yourself!

Sean Bergeson
Sean Bergeson

I highly recommend Lucy's, this is my go to place in the area for quality and delicious pizza. I've convinced many of my coworkers that this is the spot for takeout that everyone will enjoy, and now they are each believers (not one slice was left after our work lunch today!) Shout-out on this specific visit specifically to Will and Noah doing the cooking, as well as Lindsay up front as the cashier. These folks definitely know how to take care of the customer, thank you!

Paul Shumway
Paul Shumway

Wanted to try a new place. Took a while to be greeted since she was on the phone taking orders. That's fine. Sat down and with a couple minutes our server arrived. Ordered drinks, they came, then ordered a small pepperoni calzone (still good sized), bread sticks, and a chicken club sandwich. Now the wait begins. Wasn't exactly attended to much so drinks ran dry. Heard our waiter is new so okay but should be trained to never let drinks go dry. It took about, 30 minutes for the bread sticks. Very heavy on the garlic butter. I'd recommend backing off on that. Still good bread and great flavor. Five minutes later the rest of the food came. Very hot and very delicious! I'd highly recommend this place based on the food alone. A lot of pizzas went out the door as we waited and after we got our food so maybe that's why it took so long? Prices are very competitive too. I'd eat here before getting something from another chain pizza shop.

Danny
Danny

So glad we came!!! Great pizza. They’ve got the fundamentals locked down! We loved it! Pepperoni, olive, and ricotta cheese. Mmmm :)

Tyler Parcell
Tyler Parcell

This is the best pizza I have ever had. I would definitely get the zestpian

Lisy Stevens
Lisy Stevens

I’ve lived in Utah for 2 years and this has been my favorite pizza place so far! I tried it for the first time today and the slices were HUGE, they gave us ranch for free (so kind!) and normal cups for water because they were out, which is a score for me because I drink a lot of water. The pizza was crispy and the slices were cheap because of Happy Hour! 10/10 recommend and I will be coming back!

Location

If you're craving an authentic slice of New York-style pizza, look no further than Lucy's New York Style Pizza. Nestled in the heart of Orem, Utah at 59 S State St, this pizzeria has made a name for itself not only through its delectable food but also through the countless rave reviews from satisfied customers. With a phone call away at +1 801-802-7777, Lucy's is ready to cater to your pizza desires.

Lucy's menu showcases a delightful array of offerings, from classic cheese slices for just $4.00 to gourmet calzones and hearty subs. Each dish is crafted with love, embodying the spirit of New York's vibrant pizza culture. For those looking to indulge, the Large Calzone - Margherita, filled with fresh tomatoes and basil, is a refreshing choice at $13.00. Alternatively, savor the Supreme Calzone ($16.00) loaded with pepperoni, peppers, and more, for a burst of flavors in every bite.

  • Chicken Parmesan Sub - A hand-breaded chicken breast smothered in homemade marinara and mozzarella ($9.50).
  • Meatball Sub - This hearty 10-ounce meatball with marinara and cheese is a crowd-pleaser at $10.00.
  • Firesticks - A must-try for spice lovers, recommended by satisfied patrons and perfect for sharing.

Customer reviews speak volumes about the quality and atmosphere at Lucy's. One patron, Dallin Knudson, shares, "Just got myself a beautiful pizza stone and Lucy’s pizza was kind enough to sell me their amazing pizza dough—it was spectacular!" This sentiment resonates with many who find Lucy's pizza not just a meal, but a family experience.

Another enthusiastic fan, Tori Bright, states, "This is the best pizza in Utah... Lucy’s actually does!" Such a strong endorsement highlights not only the pizza’s authenticity but also the welcoming vibe that makes Lucy’s a go-to spot for gatherings and celebrations. The ambiance is as inviting as the food, making it a place you'll want to return to time and time again.

Aside from pizzas, the emphasis on quality ingredients is evident in their carefully crafted BBQ Chicken Calzone and classic Roni Slice, both priced affordably at $4.00. Customers have praised the thin, wood-fired crust and the perfect balance of sauce and toppings, further solidifying Lucy's reputation as a premier pizzeria in Utah.

In conclusion, Lucy's New York Style Pizza is more than a restaurant; it's a treasured slice of New York in Utah. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite, ordering for a family gathering, or picking up pizza dough to create your masterpiece at home, Lucy's guarantees a memorable experience with every visit. Don’t miss the opportunity to discover the delicious offerings waiting for you at this local gem!